The Relation between Degrees of Belief and Binary Beliefs: A General Impossibility Theorem

Franz Dietrich and Christian List
Additional contact information
Christian List: LSE - London School of Economics and Political Science

Post-Print from HAL

Abstract: Agents are often assumed to have degrees of belief ("credences") and also binary beliefs ("beliefs simpliciter"). How are these related to each other? A much-discussed answer asserts that it is rational to believe a proposition if and only if one has a high enough degree of belief in it. But this answer runs into the "lottery paradox": the set of believed propositions may violate the key rationality conditions of consistency and deductive closure. In earlier work, we showed that this problem generalizes: there exists no local function from degrees of belief to binary beliefs that satisfies some minimal conditions of rationality and non-triviality. "Locality" means that the binary belief in each proposition depends only on the degree of belief in that proposition, not on the degrees of belief in others. One might think that the impossibility can be avoided by dropping the assumption that binary beliefs are a function of degrees of belief. We prove that, even if we drop the "functionality" restriction, there still exists no local relation between degrees of belief and binary beliefs that satisfies some minimal conditions. Thus functionality is not the source of the impossibility; its source is the condition of locality. If there is any non-trivial relation between degrees of belief and binary beliefs at all, it must be a "holistic" one. We explore several concrete forms this "holistic" relation could take.

Keywords: construction of binary beliefs from subjective probabilities; impossibility theorem; binary beliefs (yes/no); subjective probabilities (search for similar items in EconPapers)
Date: 2021-02
References: Add references at CitEc
Citations: View citations in EconPapers (3)

Published in Igor Douven. Lotteries, Knowledge, and Rational Belief: Essays on the Lottery Paradox, Cambridge University Press, pp.223-254, 2021, 9781108421911

There are no downloads for this item, see the EconPapers FAQ for hints about obtaining it.

Related works:
Working Paper: The Relation between Degrees of Belief and Binary Beliefs: A General Impossibility Theorem (2021)
Working Paper: The Relation between Degrees of Belief and Binary Beliefs: A General Impossibility Theorem (2021)
Working Paper: The relation between degrees of belief and binary beliefs: A general impossibility theorem (2019)
Working Paper: The relation between degrees of belief and binary beliefs: A general impossibility theorem (2019)
Working Paper: The relation between degrees of belief and binary beliefs: A general impossibility theorem (2019)
This item may be available elsewhere in EconPapers: Search for items with the same title.

Export reference: BibTeX RIS (EndNote, ProCite, RefMan) HTML/Text

Persistent link: https://EconPapers.repec.org/RePEc:hal:journl:halshs-03344183

Access Statistics for this paper

More papers in Post-Print from HAL
Bibliographic data for series maintained by CCSD ().