Active versus passive investment strategy and market outperformance: are hedge funds overrated?
Julius Pauli and
Agnieszka Gehringer
Studies in Economics and Finance, 2026, vol. 43, issue 5, 1222-1252
Abstract:
PurposeThis paper aims to contribute to the active-versus-passive investment debate by examining whether hedge funds generate market outperformance and, more broadly, whether they create value beyond persistent alpha. While hedge funds are often perceived as vehicles for superior returns, their continued growth despite high fees raises the question of what explains their attractiveness if consistent outperformance is absent. The study therefore evaluates both alpha generation and alternative sources of portfolio value, including diversification benefits and downside-risk mitigation.Design/methodology/approachThe analysis is based on a comprehensive sample of 3,828 hedge funds with monthly observations from February 2014 to January 2024. Market-adjusted performance is estimated using established asset-pricing frameworks, including Jensen’s alpha model, the Fama–French multi-factor model and the Fung–Hsieh hedge fund factor model. Beyond average alpha estimates, the study examines the cross-sectional distribution of excess returns, market beta exposure and implications for portfolio efficiency and risk-adjusted performance.FindingsThe results show no consistent evidence of market outperformance: average alpha estimates are statistically indistinguishable from zero across the sample. However, important distributional patterns emerge. Over the 10-year horizon, more hedge funds achieved positive than negative excess returns. Moreover, hedge funds exhibit relatively low and often asymmetric market betas, indicating that their value lies less in persistent alpha generation and more in enhancing portfolio efficiency through diversification and downside-risk mitigation. These benefits are particularly relevant during periods of market stress.Research limitations/implicationsHedge fund data sets often exclude funds that closed or stopped reporting, which may lead to upward-biased performance estimates. The authors explain in the paper how they approach this potential survivorship bias.Practical implicationsInvestors and asset managers should recalibrate expectations: hedge funds should not be viewed primarily as vehicles for beating the market, but as effective instruments for improving risk-adjusted performance and providing resilience in diversified portfolios. This is especially valid during market stress.Originality/valueThis paper extends the active-versus-passive debate by shifting the focus from alpha generation to the broader risk–return profile of hedge funds. While prior literature predominantly evaluates hedge funds on their ability to beat the market, this study highlights their context-dependent role as instruments for improving risk-adjusted performance and portfolio resilience. By emphasizing distributional patterns and beta characteristics rather than average alpha alone, the paper offers a refined perspective on the economic function of hedge funds in contemporary investment strategies.
Keywords: Hedge funds; Market outperformance; Active investment; Passive investment (search for similar items in EconPapers)
Date: 2026
References: Add references at CitEc
Citations:
Downloads: (external link)
https://www.emerald.com/sef/article/43/5/1222/1352 ... estment-strategy-and (text/html)
https://www.emerald.com/sef/article-pdf/43/5/1222/ ... f-09-2025-0670en.pdf (application/pdf)
Related works:
This item may be available elsewhere in EconPapers: Search for items with the same title.
Export reference: BibTeX
RIS (EndNote, ProCite, RefMan)
HTML/Text
Persistent link: https://EconPapers.repec.org/RePEc:eme:sefpps:sef-09-2025-0670
DOI: 10.1108/SEF-09-2025-0670
Access Statistics for this article
Studies in Economics and Finance is currently edited by Prof Niklas Wagner
More articles in Studies in Economics and Finance from Emerald Group Publishing Limited
Bibliographic data for series maintained by Emerald Support ().